py/objtype: Don't delegate lookup of descriptor methods to __getattr__.
Some checks failed
JavaScript code lint and formatting with Biome / eslint (push) Has been cancelled
Check code formatting / code-formatting (push) Has been cancelled
Check code size / build (push) Has been cancelled
Check spelling with codespell / codespell (push) Has been cancelled
Check commit message formatting / build (push) Has been cancelled
Build docs / build (push) Has been cancelled
Check examples / embedding (push) Has been cancelled
Package mpremote / build (push) Has been cancelled
.mpy file format and tools / test (push) Has been cancelled
Build ports metadata / build (push) Has been cancelled
cc3200 port / build (push) Has been cancelled
esp32 port / build_idf (esp32_build_cmod_spiram_s2) (push) Has been cancelled
esp32 port / build_idf (esp32_build_s3_c3) (push) Has been cancelled
esp8266 port / build (push) Has been cancelled
mimxrt port / build (push) Has been cancelled
nrf port / build (push) Has been cancelled
powerpc port / build (push) Has been cancelled
qemu port / build_and_test_arm (push) Has been cancelled
qemu port / build_and_test_rv32 (push) Has been cancelled
renesas-ra port / build_renesas_ra_board (push) Has been cancelled
rp2 port / build (push) Has been cancelled
samd port / build (push) Has been cancelled
stm32 port / build_stm32 (stm32_misc_build) (push) Has been cancelled
stm32 port / build_stm32 (stm32_nucleo_build) (push) Has been cancelled
stm32 port / build_stm32 (stm32_pyb_build) (push) Has been cancelled
unix port / minimal (push) Has been cancelled
unix port / reproducible (push) Has been cancelled
unix port / standard (push) Has been cancelled
unix port / standard_v2 (push) Has been cancelled
unix port / coverage (push) Has been cancelled
unix port / coverage_32bit (push) Has been cancelled
unix port / nanbox (push) Has been cancelled
unix port / float (push) Has been cancelled
unix port / stackless_clang (push) Has been cancelled
unix port / float_clang (push) Has been cancelled
unix port / settrace (push) Has been cancelled
unix port / settrace_stackless (push) Has been cancelled
unix port / macos (push) Has been cancelled
unix port / qemu_mips (push) Has been cancelled
unix port / qemu_arm (push) Has been cancelled
unix port / qemu_riscv64 (push) Has been cancelled
webassembly port / build (push) Has been cancelled
windows port / build-vs (Debug, x64, windows-2022, dev, 2022, [17, 18)) (push) Has been cancelled
windows port / build-vs (Debug, x64, windows-latest, dev, 2017, [15, 16)) (push) Has been cancelled
windows port / build-vs (Debug, x86, windows-2022, dev, 2022, [17, 18)) (push) Has been cancelled
windows port / build-vs (Debug, x86, windows-latest, dev, 2017, [15, 16)) (push) Has been cancelled
windows port / build-vs (Release, x64, windows-2019, dev, 2019, [16, 17)) (push) Has been cancelled
windows port / build-vs (Release, x64, windows-2019, standard, 2019, [16, 17)) (push) Has been cancelled
windows port / build-vs (Release, x64, windows-2022, dev, 2022, [17, 18)) (push) Has been cancelled
windows port / build-vs (Release, x64, windows-2022, standard, 2022, [17, 18)) (push) Has been cancelled
windows port / build-vs (Release, x64, windows-latest, dev, 2017, [15, 16)) (push) Has been cancelled
windows port / build-vs (Release, x64, windows-latest, standard, 2017, [15, 16)) (push) Has been cancelled
windows port / build-vs (Release, x86, windows-2019, dev, 2019, [16, 17)) (push) Has been cancelled
windows port / build-vs (Release, x86, windows-2019, standard, 2019, [16, 17)) (push) Has been cancelled
windows port / build-vs (Release, x86, windows-2022, dev, 2022, [17, 18)) (push) Has been cancelled
windows port / build-vs (Release, x86, windows-2022, standard, 2022, [17, 18)) (push) Has been cancelled
windows port / build-vs (Release, x86, windows-latest, dev, 2017, [15, 16)) (push) Has been cancelled
windows port / build-vs (Release, x86, windows-latest, standard, 2017, [15, 16)) (push) Has been cancelled
windows port / build-mingw (i686, mingw32, dev) (push) Has been cancelled
windows port / build-mingw (i686, mingw32, standard) (push) Has been cancelled
windows port / build-mingw (x86_64, mingw64, dev) (push) Has been cancelled
windows port / build-mingw (x86_64, mingw64, standard) (push) Has been cancelled
windows port / cross-build-on-linux (push) Has been cancelled
zephyr port / build (push) Has been cancelled
Python code lint and formatting with ruff / ruff (push) Has been cancelled

When descriptors are enabled, lookup of the `__get__`, `__set__` and
`__delete__` descriptor methods should not be delegated to `__getattr__`.
That follows CPython behaviour.

Signed-off-by: Damien George <damien@micropython.org>
This commit is contained in:
Damien George
2024-10-01 10:26:27 +10:00
parent 3fecab58a0
commit 1b89c503db
2 changed files with 34 additions and 0 deletions

View File

@@ -660,6 +660,13 @@ static void mp_obj_instance_load_attr(mp_obj_t self_in, qstr attr, mp_obj_t *des
// try __getattr__
if (attr != MP_QSTR___getattr__) {
#if MICROPY_PY_DESCRIPTORS
// With descriptors enabled, don't delegate lookups of __get__/__set__/__delete__.
if (attr == MP_QSTR___get__ || attr == MP_QSTR___set__ || attr == MP_QSTR___delete__) {
return;
}
#endif
#if MICROPY_PY_DELATTR_SETATTR
// If the requested attr is __setattr__/__delattr__ then don't delegate the lookup
// to __getattr__. If we followed CPython's behaviour then __setattr__/__delattr__

View File

@@ -21,14 +21,41 @@ m = Main()
try:
m.__class__
except AttributeError:
# Target doesn't support __class__.
print("SKIP")
raise SystemExit
r = m.Forward
if 'Descriptor' in repr(r.__class__):
# Target doesn't support descriptors.
print('SKIP')
raise SystemExit
# Test assignment and deletion.
print(r)
m.Forward = 'a'
del m.Forward
# Test that lookup of descriptors like __get__ are not passed into __getattr__.
class NonDescriptor:
def __getattr__(self, attr):
print("getattr", attr)
class TestClass:
non_descriptor = NonDescriptor()
print(isinstance(TestClass().non_descriptor, NonDescriptor))
t = TestClass()
t.non_descriptor = 123
print(t.non_descriptor)
try:
del TestClass().non_descriptor
except AttributeError:
print("AttributeError")